Lemmy is not a Reddit replacement in size. On November 21, 2026, the whole network had about 31,500 monthly active accounts by FediDB's count. But the communities that matter for software (technology, self-hosting, privacy, Linux, open source) each have tens of thousands of subscribers, and a lot of their posts are literally "what's a good alternative to X?"
So the useful question isn't "should I move my Reddit playbook to Lemmy." It's "is my product the kind of thing Lemmy people are already asking for, and can I show up without breaking the rules." I pulled the numbers from Lemmy's public API, read the rules on the big instances, and wrote down what I'd do.
Disclosure: I build Needle, which finds public posts where people ask for a tool and drafts a reply for a human to review. Lemmy is one of the networks it covers. Weigh my take accordingly.
In brief
- Why now: Reddit stopped accepting new public API access requests on Oct 31, 2026, ended RSS feeds on Nov 13, 2026, and plans to close remaining public Data API access in March 2027 (PPC Land, TechCrunch). Reddit itself is fine. Watching it with your own scripts is what's getting harder.
- Lemmy is small but concentrated. About 31,500 monthly actives network-wide, with technology@lemmy.world at 89,937 subscribers and selfhosted@lemmy.world at 63,948 (checked Nov 21, 2026).
- Skip the startup communities. startups@lemmy.world had 85 subscribers. Your buyers show up in problem communities, not founder ones.
- Search is per-server. Use a big instance's search scoped to one community. Unscoped keyword search is noisy.
- Promotion is allowed in some places, banned in others. lemmy.world allows relevant, engaging promotion; lemmy.ml and sh.itjust.works list "No Ads / Spamming"; privacy@lemmy.ml says "Don't promote proprietary software."
What's actually happening with Reddit's API
I want to be calm about this because a lot of coverage isn't. Reddit announced the changes on September 30, 2026, according to TechCrunch's report by Sarah Perez and PPC Land's timeline (I relied on secondary coverage rather than the r/modnews post itself):
| Date | What changes (per coverage, checked Nov 21, 2026) |
|---|---|
| Oct 31, 2026 | Reddit stops accepting new requests for public API access |
| Nov 13, 2026 | RSS feeds end. For feeds outside communities you moderate, Reddit said "there's no replacement" (TechCrunch) |
| Jan 12, 2027 | Access starts closing for apps and users that haven't registered with Reddit |
| March 2027 | Remaining public API access closes (no exact day given) |
Reddit is still where most of these conversations happen, and you can still read and post there like any person. What's going away is cheap programmatic access, which is how a lot of founders (and tools) watched for buying-intent posts. I covered the details in the Reddit API access guide.
That's the context for looking at Lemmy. Not because it will replace Reddit, but because it's the closest thing in format, and its API is open.
What is Lemmy, and how does federation change things?
Lemmy is open-source, Reddit-style forum software: communities, posts, comments, upvotes. The difference is that there isn't one Lemmy site. There are hundreds of independently run servers ("instances") that share content with each other over ActivityPub, the same protocol Mastodon uses.
The official getting-started guide describes it as many independent servers where "users on different instances can still see each other's posts." Communities are addressed as !name@instance, so !selfhosted@lemmy.world is the self-hosting community that lives on lemmy.world. An account on any instance can subscribe and post there.
Three things about federation matter for a founder:
- There is no global search index. Each instance only knows about communities and posts that have federated to it. A tiny instance may not have a niche community at all until someone there subscribes to it. If you search from a small server, you see less.
- Big instances see the most. lemmy.world is the largest instance I checked by a wide margin, so its search covers the most federated content. When I searched selfhosted@lemmy.world from lemmy.world, results came from users on lemmy.zip, piefed.social, sh.itjust.works, lemmy.dbzer0.com, thelemmy.club and others. That's federation working in your favour.
- Rules stack. Your post has to follow your own instance's rules, the community's rules, and in practice the rules of the community's home instance. More on that below.
How big is Lemmy in 2026? Real numbers
I pulled these from each instance's public /api/v3/site endpoint and from FediDB on November 21, 2026. No login needed.
Network-wide (FediDB): 403 instances, 453,426 registered accounts, 31,520 monthly active accounts (fedidb.org/software/lemmy).
The largest instances (their own site stats):
| Instance | Registered local accounts | Active last day | Active last month | Communities known |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| lemmy.world | 202,296 | 4,680 | 13,132 | 13,622 |
| sh.itjust.works | 35,393 | 915 | 2,171 | 1,096 |
| lemmy.ml | 59,104 | 595 | 1,816 | 4,791 |
| feddit.org | 6,761 | 574 | 1,462 | 468 |
| programming.dev | 12,767 | 319 | 808 | 461 |
The gap between "registered" and "active last month" is the story. lemmy.world has over 200,000 accounts but about 13,000 that were active in the past month. Most registered accounts on Lemmy are dormant. When you see a big Lemmy number quoted somewhere, check whether it's registered or active.
Which Lemmy communities matter for software and startups?
I looked up each community on its home instance through /api/v3/community?name=... on November 21, 2026. "Active last month" is the community's monthly active users as counted by its home instance, which includes people from other servers.
| Community | Subscribers | Active last month | Created | What it's good for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| technology@lemmy.world | 89,937 | 15,783 | 2023-06 | Tech news and argument. Not support questions |
| linux@lemmy.ml | 68,860 | 5,087 | 2019-06 | Linux users, desktop and server tools |
| selfhosted@lemmy.world | 63,948 | 5,209 | 2023-06 | The best "alternative to X" community on Lemmy |
| asklemmy@lemmy.ml | 56,209 | 3,456 | 2019-04 | General questions, recommendations |
| privacy@lemmy.ml | 52,175 | 6,139 | 2019-11 | Privacy tools (no proprietary promotion) |
| nostupidquestions@lemmy.world | 50,774 | 5,658 | 2023-06 | Broad questions, some "what do you use" |
| opensource@lemmy.ml | 50,202 | 4,468 | 2019-08 | Open-source projects and news |
| fediverse@lemmy.world | 45,024 | 4,819 | 2023-06 | Fediverse software and apps |
| programming@programming.dev | 29,342 | 3,712 | 2023-06 | Developer discussion |
| homeassistant@lemmy.world | 21,328 | 577 | 2023-06 | Smart home, integrations |
| degoogle@lemmy.ml | 18,266 | 1,330 | 2020-02 | People actively leaving Google products |
| opensource@programming.dev | 7,058 | 1,618 | 2023-09 | Smaller, more developer-heavy open source |
| webdev@programming.dev | 5,970 | 393 | 2023-06 | Web developers (quiet) |
And the ones you'd expect a founder to start with:
| Community | Subscribers | Posts ever |
|---|---|---|
| startups@lemmy.world | 85 | 11 |
| smallbusiness@lemmy.world | 71 | 2 |
| saas@programming.dev | 87 | 7 |
Those are effectively empty. That's the main lesson of this section: on Lemmy, people gather around problems and values (self-hosting, privacy, Linux, degoogling), not around being founders. If your product solves one of those problems, the audience is there. If it's a sales tool for SMBs, it mostly isn't.
How to search Lemmy across instances
Find communities: lemmyverse.net
Lemmyverse indexes communities across instances, and both the official guide and sh.itjust.works' sidebar point people to it. Search your problem space ("selfhosted", "devops", "photography") and sort by subscribers. Then open the community on its home instance and read the sidebar rules before anything else.
Find posts: the search API
Every Lemmy instance exposes the same public API. The Lemmy API docs page points to the OpenAPI reference; the endpoint you want is /api/v3/search. Two calls I ran, no credentials:
# Noisy: unscoped keyword search across everything lemmy.world knows
https://lemmy.world/api/v3/search?q=looking%20for%20a%20tool&type_=Posts&sort=New&listing_type=All&limit=50
# Useful: the same idea, scoped to one community
https://lemmy.world/api/v3/search?q=alternative&type_=Posts&sort=New&listing_type=All&community_name=selfhosted@lemmy.world&limit=20
The unscoped search matched the words anywhere, not as a phrase. My "looking for a tool" query returned mostly automated news reposts from political feed communities, with one real ask ("anyone archiving web pages for compliance or legal reasons?" in a programming community) in the first eight results.
The scoped search was a different experience. The 20 newest posts mentioning "alternative" in selfhosted@lemmy.world included:
- "Can anyone suggest any self-built Apple TV alternatives" (56 comments)
- "what is a good self hostable alternative to facebook messenger" (42 comments)
- "Beginner looking for advice on open-source NAS hardware and OS for self-hosting" (40 comments)
- Two project launches tagged
[AIP], the community's AI-involvement disclosure tag (18 and 31 comments)
Those are real buying conversations, and the comment counts are healthy for a network this size.
Copy-paste search terms that worked well scoped to a community:
alternative
replace OR replacement
recommend
what do you use
moving away from
self-hostable
looking for
Run each per community rather than across the network, and read the comments: in "what do you use" threads, the replies are where people name tools and say why they left the last one.
Rate limits: be polite
lemmy.world's site config (returned by /api/v3/site) allows 100 searches per 600 seconds per client. That's plenty for a person, and a reminder that instances are run by volunteers on donated money. If you write a script, run it a few times a day, not every minute, and set a descriptive user agent.
Self-promotion rules on the major instances
I read the rules on November 21, 2026. Quotes are short; follow the links for the full text.
| Where | What the rules say (checked Nov 21, 2026) |
|---|---|
| lemmy.world terms | Not "a marketing channel for extensive commercial advertising or product promotion." Promotion is "generally allowed" if it's relevant to the community, "offers something of value," and is "created for community engagement rather than being a one-way message." Accounts that "primarily promote paid products or services" may be removed. Bots "shall not be used for any kind of advertising." |
| lemmy.world (sidebar) | You can't post or comment from a VPN or Tor connection |
| lemmy.ml (sidebar) | Rule 4: "No Ads / Spamming." |
| sh.itjust.works (sidebar) | "No Ads / Spamming." |
| technology@lemmy.world | "Accounts 7 days and younger will have their posts automatically removed." AI responses and summaries only from approved bots. "Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted." |
| selfhosted@lemmy.world | "Promotion posts require active participation, with an account that is at least 30 days old." Spam includes "Using scripts/bots/gen AI to automate posts and comments" and unsolicited mass DMs. |
| selfhosted AI rules | Promotion posts need a tag: [CBH] (code by human) or [AIP] (AI was used in any capacity, with a disclosure of how). "Failing to provide the disclosure will mean the removal of your post." |
| privacy@lemmy.ml | "Don't promote proprietary software." |
| opensource@lemmy.ml | "Posts must be relevant to the open source ideology." |
The pattern is consistent: value first, engagement over broadcast, honesty about AI use, and a real account history. Community rules are stricter than instance rules, so the community sidebar is the one that decides whether your post survives.
How to post and reply on Lemmy without getting banned
This is what I'd do, in order:
- Pick an instance and actually use it. lemmy.world is the default, though remember the no-VPN rule. programming.dev suits developers. Either way, read and comment for a few weeks first. Two of the communities above enforce minimum account ages (7 days and 30 days).
- Reply before you post. The highest-value action on Lemmy is answering an existing "what should I use for X" thread. Answer the question fully, including options that aren't yours.
- Disclose in the same sentence. "I work on X, so I'm biased, but..." Undisclosed promotion is the fastest way to get reported, and lemmy.world's own terms frame acceptable promotion as two-way engagement.
- Lead with what matters to this crowd. Can it be self-hosted? Is it open source? What's the license? Where is data stored? Is there a free tier without tracking? If you don't know, say so.
- Use the community's tags. On selfhosted, a promotion post without
[CBH]or[AIP]breaks the rules. If you used AI to build it, use[AIP]and fill in the disclosure honestly. - Don't cross-post the same launch everywhere. selfhosted's rules define spam as "posting the exact same post across a bunch of different communities, rapidly."
- Don't automate posting or replies. selfhosted bans it, technology@lemmy.world allows only approved bots, and lemmy.world requires bots to be marked and approved per community. Drafting with a tool is fine; a human should read and post every reply.
- Stay in the thread. Questions in comments are where trust gets built. A launch post you never return to reads as a one-way message, which is exactly what the terms warn about.
If you've done community-led outreach on Reddit, most of this will feel familiar. My guide to finding customers on Reddit without getting banned covers the same habits.
What Lemmy is bad for
I'd rather you skip Lemmy than spend a month there for nothing.
- It's small. 31,520 monthly actives across the whole network. Use Lemmy as an extra channel, not your main one.
- It skews technical, privacy-minded and FOSS. The biggest communities are technology, Linux, self-hosting, privacy and open source. If your buyer is a marketing manager or a dentist, they're probably not here.
- Anti-corporate sentiment is real. Several communities spell out their values in their rules ("Don't promote proprietary software," "relevant to the open source ideology"). A closed-source SaaS pitch will often be downvoted even when it technically follows the rules.
- Founder and business communities are empty. See the table above. There's no r/SaaS equivalent with real traffic.
- Search is fragmented. There's no single index, and unscoped search is noisy. You'll do more manual work per useful thread than on a centralized site.
Where Lemmy is good: open-source tools, self-hostable software with a paid cloud version, privacy products, developer tools, Linux apps, and anything positioned as an alternative to a big-tech product. If that's you, the selfhosted, privacy and degoogle communities are some of the most receptive audiences on the open web, as long as you respect their norms.
For the wider fediverse context (including why Mastodon is a weaker research source than it looks), see Mastodon and fediverse market research: cautions. For developer audiences specifically, the Lobsters vs Hacker News culture guide and the Hacker News playbook are the next places I'd look.
A simple weekly Lemmy routine
- Monday: On lemmyverse.net, find three to five communities that match your problem space. Note subscribers and how recent the last posts are. Skip anything with no posts this month.
- Daily, 10 minutes: Run scoped searches ("alternative", "recommend", "what do you use") in those communities from lemmy.world. Sort by New.
- Reply to one or two threads where you can genuinely help. Disclose if you mention your product.
- Once a month at most: A launch or update post, in one community, with the right tag, from an account with history.
If you'd rather not run the searches yourself, a few tools now cover Lemmy. Needle's Lemmy page explains how we search posts and comments on large instances (lemmy.world and programming.dev) and leave the posting to you. A small script against /api/v3/search also works fine at this scale, and it's free.
Evidence notes
All checked November 21, 2026.
- Reddit timeline: TechCrunch, Sep 30, 2026 (RSS Nov 13, registration deadline Jan 12, 2027, public API March 2027, "there's no replacement"); PPC Land, Oct 4, 2026 (new requests stop Oct 31, 2026). I did not read the original r/modnews post.
- Network stats: FediDB Lemmy page via its public API (
api.fedidb.org/v1/software/lemmy): 403 instances, 453,426 users, 31,520 monthly actives. - Instance stats:
https://<instance>/api/v3/sitefor lemmy.world, lemmy.ml, sh.itjust.works, feddit.org and programming.dev. lemmy.world's search rate limit (100 per 600 seconds) is from the same response. - Community stats:
https://<home instance>/api/v3/community?name=<name>for each community in the tables. Counts change daily. - Searches:
https://lemmy.world/api/v3/searchwith the parameters shown above. - How Lemmy works: Lemmy getting-started guide; Lemmy API docs page; Lemmyverse.
- Rules: lemmy.world terms of service (no last-updated date shown on the page); lemmy.ml, sh.itjust.works and lemmy.world sidebars (from
/api/v3/site); community sidebars for technology@lemmy.world, selfhosted@lemmy.world, privacy@lemmy.ml and opensource@lemmy.ml (from/api/v3/community); selfhosted's detailed rules post (updated July 7, 2026) and AI and promotional post rules. - programming.dev links its own Code of Conduct from its sidebar, but the page sat behind a browser challenge when I tried to read it, so I haven't quoted it. Read it before posting there.